MIXER COMPARISON GUIDE AND CHART
If you're a home baker producing in bulk, choosing the right mixer is one of the most important decisions you’ll make.
If you're a home baker producing in bulk, choosing the right mixer is one of the most important decisions you’ll make. A great mixer doesn’t just save time—it improves dough development, increases consistency, and allows you to scale up without overworking yourself.
I created a comparison chart with the elements that actually matter when comparing mixers. The chart -and my ultimate recommendation- is at the end of this post.
This guide explains how to understand each aspect of the chart, so you can pick the best mixer for your needs. Let me know in the comments if you have other questions, so I can improve this guide to cover everything.
Understanding the Different Mixer Types In The Chart
🌍 Planetary Mixers (KitchenAid, Bosch, Hobart)
The attachment (hook, paddle, or whisk) rotates around a stationary bowl—just like a planet orbiting the sun.
These mixers are versatile because they can mix everything from bread dough to cake batter and cookies.
They are a better all-around choice if you bake a variety of items.
Typically the bowls are detachable, making them easier to clean.
🌀 Spiral Mixers (Vevor, Estella)
The bowl spins while the dough hook stays in place, stretching and kneading the dough gently.
This mimics hand-kneading, making it ideal for bread dough, especially high-hydration doughs like sourdough.
If bread is your main focus, and gluten development is really important to you during the mixing stage, then a spiral mixer is the best option for large batches.
Typically the bowls are not detachable, making them harder to clean.
⚙️ Unique Bowl-Driven Mixer (Ankarsrum Assistent)
The bowl rotates while a roller and scraper knead the dough, making it a little different from planetary and spiral mixers.
It has a learning curve because it functions differently. I do not own this one, but I have heard the learning curve is quite… curvy.
This mixer is versatile but leans towards softer dough. In the videos I have watched, the roller seems to struggle with tougher doughs.
Motor Power – Why Watts Aren’t Everything
It’s easy to assume that a higher wattage means a stronger mixer, but that’s not always the case.
Here’s what actually matters:
Watts measure power consumption, not necessarily the efficiency or torque of the motor.
A well-engineered lower-watt motor (like Hobart’s 960W motor) can outperform a higher-wattage motor because of better internal gearing and torque.
Torque is key for bread dough—a mixer with high torque and strong gears will knead dough better than one with just a high wattage rating.
👉 Takeaway: A lower-wattage motor on a commercial-grade mixer will often last longer and perform better than a higher-wattage consumer mixer with cheaper parts.
Capacity – More Than Just Bowl Size
You might think a bigger bowl = more capacity, but it’s not just about the bowl size. The real mixing capacity is determined by:
Bowl shape – Taller, narrower bowls (like in planetary mixers) can limit how much dough is effectively mixed.
Hooks, paddles, whisks, etc – attachments are designed differently across mixers. Some perform well with small batches, while others require the bowl to be at least half full for optimal mixing.
Motor power & design – A weak motor might struggle with a full bowl of stiff dough, even if the bowl is large.
👉 Takeaway: Don’t just look at quart size—consider the mixer's actual capacity based on the number of loaves or cookies it can mix. Don’t believe everything the manufacturer says. You have to ask real bakers and that’s what this guide is for.
Warranty – A Reflection of Quality
The length of a warranty tells you a lot about the company’s confidence in its product.
Shorter warranties (1 year) → Common on lower-end or budget mixers, meaning they may not last as long under heavy use.
Longer warranties (3-7 years) → Typically found on high-end mixers, showing a commitment to durability and customer support.
Hobart only offers 1-year on commercial models because they assume heavy use, but their mixers often last decades without issues.
👉 Takeaway: A longer warranty suggests better build quality, but Hobart’s 1-year warranty doesn’t mean it’s a low-quality mixer—it’s just built for commercial use.
Where Mixers Are Made & Why It Matters
The place of origin affects build quality, materials, and parts sourcing.
USA-made mixers (Hobart, KitchenAid) – Good quality standards, but some KitchenAid parts are sourced globally.
European-made mixers (Ankarsrum, Bosch) – Typically very well-engineered, designed for longevity.
China-made mixers (Vevor, Estella) – More affordable but vary in quality—some perform well, others may have lower-grade components.
👉 Takeaway: Country of manufacture can impact long-term reliability, but brand reputation and engineering matter just as much.
Price – Why It Varies & What to Expect
Build quality & materials – Commercial-grade metal parts cost more than plastic components.
Motor strength & durability – Higher-end models have better motors that last longer under heavy use.
Brand reputation – Established brands like Hobart, Bosch, and Ankarsrum command higher prices due to reliability.
⚠️ Prices and specifications are subject to change. Always verify details with retailers before purchasing.
Understanding Larger Mixers
Larger mixers follow a pretty proportional increase in capacity.
A Estella 30qt can hold 22 loaves of 900 grams (I have mixed up to 25, but the flour starts flying everywhere)
I am still researching the real capacity of larger machines like a 60qt mixer, I will update later.
Final Thoughts – Which Mixer Should You Get?
Your ideal mixer depends on:
What you bake most (bread → spiral, variety → planetary).
How much you bake (small batches → KitchenAid/Bosch, bulk → Estella/Hobart).
Your budget (affordable → Vevor, premium → Ankarsrum, Hobart).
No matter which mixer you choose, having the right tool makes baking easier, faster, and more enjoyable. I hope this guide helps you make the best decision for your home bakery!
My recommendation
For the typical home baker making no more than 60 loaves of sourdough per week (or the equivalent in other bakes), I highly recommend the Bosch Universal Plus Mixer. It’s European-made, built to high-quality standards, and has been a trusted choice for generations of bakers. The Bosch is known for its versatility, effortlessly handling smaller batches (1-2 loaves) and larger batches (5-6 loaves) with consistent results. It has outstanding reviews, a strong motor, and an efficient dough-mixing system that makes it an excellent investment for most home bakeries.
However, if your home bakery is already producing over 60 loaves per week, has sustained this demand for a while, and you’re sure you want to scale further, then I would recommend upgrading to a 30-quart Estella spiral mixer to increase your efficiency and capacity.
Affiliate Links Disclosure
Some links in this guide may be affiliate links, meaning I earn a small commission at no cost to you if you make a purchase. This helps support the research, testing, and effort that went into creating this one-of-a-kind comparison chart for home bakers. I appreciate your support! ❤️
If you love my content, please consider sharing it with friends and family. Every share helps spread this movement — and as a thank you, you’ll unlock even more exclusive recipes and behind-the-scenes content.